
THE MARKETING MISFITS NEWSLETTER
Issue #036 | Nov 11, 2026
FROM AMAZON TO REAL SHELVES
ONE QUESTION. NO GOOGLING.
According to Korie Minkus, what percentage of all US retail spending still happens in physical stores, and how often do retail buyers typically rotate roles?
Answer at bottom of email
HOT OFF THE PRESS! [ YESTERDAY ]
From generative B-roll to digital avatars replacing human actors, the reality of commercial filmmaking is shifting much faster than you think. Are you ready for what comes next?
In this episode of Marketing Misfits, hosts Norm Farrar and Kevin King sit down with veteran commercial director Stewart Cohen to discuss how technology is radically shifting the way brands tell stories. From his days editing on physical film and shipping massive laserdiscs for General Motors, to now using generative AI to create completely synthetic b-roll for national Christmas commercials, Stewart has seen it all.
Stewart discusses why authenticity and the "shot on iPhone" look have dominated since COVID, why big-budget commercials are now shot entirely on virtual walls, and the terrifying reality of SAG actors choosing to license their digital likenesses rather than show up to set.

This edition is made possible by:
DataDoe connects all your Amazon data, Seller Central, Vendor Central and Amazon Ads plus the product costs you upload, to Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini, Grok or any other AI tool that supports MCP.
You ask about your business in plain English and get answers from your own numbers. Then you act on it: Claude can change prices, edit or create listings and manage your PPC, and each change waits for your approval first.
One plan, $97 a month.
New accounts get a 14-day free trial, then code NORM50 takes 50% off the first paid month.
This was also made possible by:
Levanta: One platform to run your entire affiliate and creator program across Amazon, Shopify, and Walmart — Marketing Misfits listeners get 10% off. Grab your discount.
QuietLight Brokerage: Get a free, confidential valuation
Sellerboard: Master your ecom profits and expenses
House of AMZ: Elevate your brand today
8fig: Get 25% off 8fig off
Stack Influence: Use code MISFITS for 10% off
MISFIT STORY of the WEEK
The Costco Email That Left a Founder Flabbergasted
Korie Minkus spent 35 years inside the consumer products industry before she ever launched her own consultancy, watching trade shows and buyer meetings unfold from the inside in a way most Amazon founders never get to see.
She served on the advisory board of the Nutrition Capital Network, building relationships with buyers at nearly every major US retailer along the way, long before Amazon existed as a channel at all.
The story that convinced her most Amazon founders were sitting on an enormous blind spot involved a brand she was consulting for, one that was already crushing it on Amazon, pulling in low single digit millions in annual revenue, but had never once pitched a physical retailer.
Korie helped the founder put together a pitch for Costco, using the brand's Amazon sales data and reviews as proof of concept rather than starting from scratch with a traditional retail deck.
When the buyer's email came back, it did not come back with a maybe or a request for samples. It came back with a yes, and not a small yes. An initial order for 1,500 stores. The founder, in Korie's own words, was "flabbergasted." He had spent years quietly assuming that physical retail was some kind of closed club, gatekept by relationships and connections he did not have.
It was not a closed club. It was a process, and nobody had ever shown him the steps.
Since that moment, Korie has reviewed more than 5,000 pitch decks and helped brands land first orders at national chains totaling 1,500 stores or more. She built her Rock Your Product framework, which she calls the Retail Confidence Architecture, entirely around one goal: translating three
THE CHALKBOARD
Amazon Was Never the Whole Business. It Was Supposed to Be the Warmup.

This week pairs Korie Minkus's practical framework for taking an Amazon brand into physical retail with Mike McClary's blunt assessment of whether Amazon-only selling is still a viable long-term strategy at all.
Both conversations land on the same core message from different directions: brands that treat Amazon as their entire business are exposed in ways that brands with real omnichannel distribution simply are not.
Korie's number should stop every Amazon-only founder cold: 83 percent of all US retail spending still happens in physical stores. Mike's warning runs in parallel, built around a line he attributes to Jeff Bezos: "your margin is my opportunity." If your Amazon margins are healthy, Mike argues, Amazon will eventually
Marketer's Notepad:
Amazon is not your competitor to retail. It is your 24/7 focus group, Korie says, meaning your Amazon reviews and sales data are actually the strongest proof points you can bring into a retail buyer pitch.
Retail buyers rotate roles roughly every six months, according to Korie, which means re-pitching a retailer that said no last year is not desperate. It is simply smart timing.
Mike's recommended channel sequence after Amazon: your own site first, then Shopify, then TikTok Shop, then Walmart, with each step compounding the value of the one before it.
Did you know case pack economics work completely differently than single-unit Amazon economics? Founders who price a retail case pack using Amazon-style per-unit math frequently lose money on their very first purchase order.
Korie's advice on packaging: a photo or signature from the founder printed on the box builds retail trust in a way a logo alone never quite manages.
Walmart is embracing AI-driven, agentic commerce faster than Amazon, per Mike, creating a real window of opportunity for sellers willing to set up there proactively rather than waiting.
What would it actually take for your brand to run a small, regional retail test before attempting a national pitch? Korie recommends starting local specifically to learn the retail rhythm before scaling.
Watch These Misfits Episodes to Dive Deeper:
Take Your Amazon Brand to Retail (Korie Minkus)
Is Selling on Amazon Dead? (Mike McClary)
MARKETING TRENDS & FACTS

MISFIT MARKETING STRATEGY
Case-Pack Retail Positioning

Case-pack retail positioning is the strategy of preparing an Amazon-native brand's economics, packaging, and pitch materials specifically for the realities of physical retail buying, rather than assuming what works on a single-unit Amazon listing will translate directly to a national retail pitch. This distinction trips up more Amazon founders than almost any other part of the retail transition.
Why this matters: retail buyers think in pallets, not parcels. A brand that prices its case pack using the same per-unit margin structure as its Amazon listing often discovers, too late, that the economics of shipping and fulfilling a 1,500 store first order simply do not work at that price point.
The costs of a physical retail relationship, slotting fees, chargebacks, and cash flow timing, are structurally different from selling one unit at a time online.
How to build case-pack retail positioning in practice:
Rebuild your unit economics from scratch specifically for case-pack, pallet-level shipping, rather than adjusting your existing Amazon per-unit pricing model.
Calculate the true landed cost of a case pack including freight, and set your wholesale price with enough margin to survive a large, unexpected first order.
Use your existing Amazon reviews and sales data as your retail pitch deck's proof section, screenshotting both your strongest and weakest reviews to show buyers you understand your own product honestly.
Line up cash flow options in advance, including SBA loans, factoring, or purchase order financing, since a large first retail order requires funding inventory months before payment arrives.
Redesign your packaging specifically with a retail shelf in mind, including a founder photo or signature that builds trust in a way a generic logo cannot replicate on a crowded shelf.
Start with a regional or small-format retail test (a local grocery chain, a co-op, an independent specialty retailer) before pitching a national chain, using that regional data as further proof for the bigger pitch.
The payoff of getting this right the first time is significant. A brand that shows up to a retail buyer meeting with case-pack economics already solved, cash flow already lined up, and Amazon data already packaged as proof looks fundamentally more credible than one still figuring out these basics mid-negotiation.
EMAIL MARKETING
Landing a retail placement is a genuine milestone, and too many brands treat the announcement as a single, forgettable social media post rather than the multi-email opportunity it actually represents. Your existing email subscribers are often your most loyal customers, and they can meaningfully influence a new retail relationship's early success through in-store visits and word of mouth.
Build a three-part sequence starting with a "we have big news" teaser email sent a few days before the retail launch date, hinting at the announcement without giving away the retailer's name yet if your agreement allows for building anticipation this way. This creates curiosity and primes your list to pay attention to the follow-up.
The second email is your full announcement, naming the retailer clearly, including the specific locations if the rollout is regional rather than national, and giving subscribers a clear, simple call to action: visit the store, take a photo, tag the brand. Frame this as something to celebrate together rather than a purely promotional update.
The third email, sent about a week after launch, should share real customer photos and stories from the retail rollout if you have collected any, reinforcing social proof and giving subscribers who have not yet visited a fresh reason to do so. This also doubles as content you can repurpose for the retail buyer relationship itself, showing them your brand actively drives foot traffic.
Segment this sequence geographically if your retail rollout is regional, since subscribers outside the launch area do not need the same in-store call to action and should instead receive a version focused on celebrating the milestone and building anticipation for a wider rollout.
For help with email marketing for your brand, contact dragon.fish
People don't buy what you do, they buy why you do it.
THE ONE-MINUTE CASE STUDY

The Brand: Magic Spoon built its cereal brand almost entirely on a direct-to-consumer model before making a deliberate, carefully staged move into physical retail, treating the transition as a genuine strategic decision rather than an inevitable next step every DTC brand assumes it must take. The brand had already built a loyal online following around its high-protein, low-sugar positioning within a cereal category otherwise dominated by legacy brands.
The Strategy: The strategy worked because Magic Spoon used its established DTC data and customer loyalty as a direct bargaining edge in retail buyer conversations, walking into pitch meetings with concrete proof of demand rather than asking a buyer to take a bet on an unproven product. This flipped the traditional retail pitch dynamic, where an unknown brand typically has to prove itself from zero.
The Result: Magic Spoon successfully expanded into thousands of retail doors nationally within a relatively short window after its initial retail push, a rollout speed that would have been extremely difficult to achieve without the built-in demand signal its DTC business had already established.
The Lesson: A strong, well-documented DTC track record is not just a revenue stream on its own, it is an edge that can dramatically speed up a retail buyer's confidence and shorten the path from first pitch to national shelf placement.
FROM NORM & KEVIN’S HUMIDOR

Choosing how to cut a cigar before smoking it changes the flavor experience more than most casual smokers realize, and the differences between the three main cutter styles are not just cosmetic preferences.
A straight cutter, the most common style, slices a clean, flat opening across the cap, offering an even, wide airflow that many smokers consider the most balanced draw.
A punch cutter removes a small circular piece from the cap instead of slicing across it, creating a tighter opening that concentrates the smoke and can make a cigar taste slightly more intense and slower burning.
A V-cutter, sometimes called a cat's eye cut, creates a wedge-shaped notch that increases the surface area of tobacco exposed to the draw, often producing a cooler smoke with more surface-level flavor from the wrapper leaf itself.
Serious cigar enthusiasts often carry more than one cutter style specifically because different cigar shapes and sizes respond better to different cuts, and a poorly chosen cut can cause a cigar to unravel, burn unevenly, or draw far too tight to enjoy properly.
The next Collective Minds Society Cigar & Whisky trip is Feb 18-22, 2027
THE MISFITS AI MARKETING TIP
How to Build a Retailer Buyer Pitch Generator

Use AI to draft the foundation of a retail buyer pitch deck by feeding it your existing Amazon data and customer proof points, following the approach Korie Minkus's clients use to speed up pitch preparation.
Gather your Amazon sales history, your top and bottom three customer reviews, and any relevant press mentions or awards your brand has received.
Feed this material to an AI model together with basic case pack details: minimum order quantity, wholesale pricing, and shipping specifics.
Ask the model to draft a three-slide "why now" section highlighting your strongest proof points in language a retail buyer would find compelling.
Ask it to draft a section addressing your weakest reviews directly and honestly, since buyers respond well to brands that own their shortcomings rather than hiding them.
Have the model draft a case-pack economics slide clearly laying out wholesale pricing, minimum order quantities, and margin structure for the buyer's reference.
Review every claim generated by the AI against your actual data before including it in a real pitch, since accuracy matters enormously in a retail buyer relationship built on trust.
Sample Prompt: "Using this Amazon sales history, these customer reviews, and this case pack pricing, draft a three-slide retail pitch deck section explaining why our brand is ready for a national retail order right now."
A pitch deck built from real data beats a generic template every single time a buyer is deciding who gets the shelf space.
MARKETING LISTS

THE FAQ (HOW’D YOU DO?)
Q: What percentage of US retail spending happens in physical stores?
Korie Minkus cites 83 percent of all US retail spending still happening in physical stores on Take Your Amazon Brand to Retail, a figure that should reframe how Amazon-only brands think about their long-term growth ceiling.
Q: How often do retail buyers change roles?
Retail buyers rotate roughly every six months according to Korie Minkus, meaning a brand rejected by one buyer should consider re-pitching once a new buyer occupies that seat rather than assuming the door is permanently closed.
Q: Should an Amazon brand start with a national retailer or a regional one?
Korie Minkus recommends starting with a regional or small-format retailer to learn the operational rhythm of physical retail before attempting a national pitch to a chain like Costco or Walmart.
Q: Is selling on Amazon still worth it, according to Mike McClary?
Mike McClary argues Amazon is not dead but cannot be a brand's only channel anymore, recommending an expansion sequence of your own
THE ANSWER YOU’RE LOOKING FOR
Eighty three percent of all US retail spending still happens in physical stores, and retail buyers typically rotate roles roughly every six months.
Korie Minkus shared that Amazon-only brands are ignoring the majority of the market and that a past rejection from a buyer is rarely permanent.
Watch the full conversation

Hope you enjoyed this week’s issue. We’ll see you next week!
Norm and Kevin
P.S.
Don’t forget to checkout the podcast too!
If you’d like to be a guest, or make a guest recommendation, please let us know!
P.S.S.
If you are looking to ramp up your email or AEO game, talk to us at DragonFish
